数学教育研究における学習者の外化と議論の重要性 : 数学の認識論、数学教育における認識論を基に
充 松島 · Shizuoka University Repository (Shizuoka University) · 2013
The purposes of this study are to investigate relation between externalization by oral language and understanding in mathematics education, and to clarify epistemology in mathematics education whichhas deep relation in a Jigsaw method. Method of this study is literature study on epistemology. Epistemology of mathematics and epistemology in mathematics education are analyzed from the standpoints of the relation between externalization by oral language and understanding in mathematics education, and from the standpoints of Sfard’s metaphors:acquisition metaphor and participation metaphor. Based on the analysis, it was clarified what kind of epistemology in mathematics education has deep relation in a Jigsaw method. Epistemology of mathematics is largely divided into absolutism and fallibilism by Ernest. Among nine types of epistemology of mathematics investigated in this paper, constructivism in absolutism, and conventionalism, empiricism, quasi-empiricism, social constructivism and anthropological approach in fallibilism are referred as epistemology relating oral language. And social constructivism is identified as an epistemology deeply referring to the relation between externalization by oral language and understanding in mathematics education. Furthermore, among eight types of epistemology in mathematics education investigated in this paper, socio-cultural approach, interactionist approach, social constructivism, anthropological approach and multi-world paradigm are referred as epistemology relating oral language. Again social constructivism is identified as an epistemology deeply referring to the relation between externalization by oral language and understanding in mathematics education. Investigating epistemology above mentioned from the standpoint of Sfard’s metaphors, absolutism is correspondence to the acquisition metaphor and fallibilism to the participation metaphor, in epistemology of mathematics. Regarding to epistemology in mathematics education, behaviorism, structuralism and radical constructivism belong to the acquisition metaphor and socio-cultural approach, interactionist approach, social constructivism and anthropological approach belong to the participation metaphor. And social constructivism is a connection of the two metaphors. In conclusion, it is suggested that the Jigsaw method which secures learner’s externalization of opinions and argumentation can be a learning methodology having epistemological basis of each of social constructivism, socio-cultural approach, interactionist approach or anthropological approach in research on mathematics education. Above all, social constructivism seems to become a strong candidate having epistemological basis for the Jigsaw method, because the social constructivism has not only a descriptiveness to account the process that mathematical subjective knowledge develops to objective knowledge, but also a normativeness to show true mathematical learning that emphasizes oral language.
Cited by 0 works. Open-access PDF