Институт религиозных конфессий и организаций с позиций русской политологической школы
С.О. Елишев · Электронное научное издание Альманах Пространство и Время · 2012
Following of state, religious confessions and organizations are second most important institution of political system of society. It is a traditions of Russian school of political science (especially in works of Konstantin Pobedonostsev, Boris Chicherin, and Lev Tikhomirov) to scrutinize institution, that denoted as in light of relationship between and According to К. Pobedonostsev, one of significant events of contemporary society was struggle between ecclesiastical principles and state ones, and main source of this struggle was the artificially created theory of relationship between and state. K. Pobedonostsev identifies three systems of relationships between and state, according to which those relations were manifested in West European history. The first system is a system of state church. The state recognizes one religion and provides supports and protects one 'true' church, not recognizing other churches as true in various forms. The second system presupposes equally impartial attitude of state to all faiths without recognizing or persecuting of any church. This state policy gives to each to arrange their affairs and ceremonies at their own discretion. It is a system of equality of churches, or a system of in a free state. The third system implies that state refrains from any preference or patronage to a particular religion or belief, only limits or prohibits such beliefs that recognizes false or harmful to society. This system is based on assumption that much easier to determine which belief is false than which one is true. In his turn, Boris Chicherin identifies four possible systems that define relationship and situation of in These are: (1) a theocracy, which is subjection of state to church, (2) dominant church, (3) recognition church, and (4) bearable church; different systems may co-exist with respect to different religions. Classification of theocracy as particular type of relationship between state and is just only difference in classifications of K. Pobedonostsev and B. Chicherin despite fact that they are representatives of opposing tendencies of conservative and liberal trends of Russian political science. L. Tikhomirov, considering history of monarchical form of statehood, identified three types of relations between state and religion: (1) transformation of supreme state power to center of religion with varying degrees of deification of monarch (paganism, caesaropapism), (2) state institutions' subjection to (the power of priests, papocaesarism), (3) an alliance of state and Church, which is achieved by subordination of monarch to religious idea and by fact that he himself belongs to church, whilst maintaining of his sovereignty. L. Tikhomirov considered that optimal form of relation between and state is allied relationship which is inherent primarily to Orthodox monarchy. Only in those states, in his view, is possible to preserve religious ethical principles’ independence from state ones without estrangement between Church and State. In this context, author believes, that currently is not quite correct to use term church applied to system relations between state and religious confessions and organizations, because it is become generally accepted in religious studies disciplines, especially sociology of religion to distinguish four types of religious organizations, such as church, sect, denomination, cult. Author also analyzes relationship between Russian state and traditional Russian confessions and discusses some difficulties in exactly determining of number of adherents of traditional religions and denominations.
Cited by 0 works.