Evaluating the Normal Approximation to the Binomial Test
Philip H. Ramsey, Patricia P. Ramsey · Journal of Educational Statistics · 1988
The normal approximation to the binomial test with and without a continuity correction is evaluated in terms of control of Type I errors and power. The normal approximations are evaluated as robust for a given sample size, N, and at a given level α if the true Type I error rate never exceeds 1.5 α. The uncorrected normal test is found to be less robust than is implied by the currently applied guidelines. The most stringent currently used guideline of requiring σ 2 ≥10 is adequate at α = .05 but must be increased to σ 2 ≥35 at α = .01. The corrected test is shown to be robust but not conservative. Both tests are shown to have substantial power loss in comparison to the exact binomial test.
Cited by 10 works. doi:10.2307/1164752
Authors
References
- Some Methods for Strengthening the Common χ 2 Tests
- Introduction to Mathematical Statistics.
- Statistics for the social sciences
- The American Statistician
- Applied Statistics
- Fundamental Research Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences.
- An Introduction to Mathematical Statistics
- Statistics (3rd ed.).
- Introduction to Mathematical Statistics.
- Psychological Statistics.