Data
Jonathan M. Samet · Epidemiology · 2009
This question (to share or to not share data) was the topic of the “The Changing Face of Epidemiology” symposium at the 2008 Annual Meeting of the Society for Epidemiological Research. The 2 presenters, Daniel Levy and Graham Colditz, offered their perspectives based on years of experience as principal investigators for the Framingham Study and the Nurses’ Health Study, respectively. Both studies are unique for the richness of the data collected, for the duration of follow-up, and for the myriad hypotheses still to be tested using their data; both are supported by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and are costly. The approaches taken for data sharing, as described by Levy and Colditz, differed. For the Framingham study, there has long been data sharing via public use data sets whereas the Nurses’ Health Study has required the submission of a proposal for review by the Principal Investigator and subsequently by the study's Advisory Committee. Levy was firm in calling for open access to data collected with public funds, as long as confidentiality and privacy of data are maintained. Colditz spoke to the realities of data sharing—the need for infrastructure, the varied approaches to data sharing issues by Institutional Review Boards, and the competing interests of study investigators and their students with those seeking data access. In this commentary, I broaden the discussion to issues that inevitably come as we enter the era of data sharing: (1) the definition of the data that are to be shared; (2) the need to develop a culture of data sharing in epidemiology; (3) the consequences of data sharing for epidemiology (as fewer new population studies are supported); and (4) the implications of data sharing for students and researchers. First, regarding the rhetorical question posed in the title of this commentary—yes, share. Regardless of whether epidemiologists want to share data, the era of data sharing has arrived. One historical landmark was the “Shelby Amendment,” a 1-sentence amendment inserted into the 1998 appropriations bill. The Shelby Amendment led to changes in the Office of Management and Budget's Circular A-110 governing research such that data collected with federal funds and cited in a regulation have to be made available if requested under the Freedom of Information Act. The Shelby Amendment was prompted by the reliance of the Environmental Protection Agency on data from the Harvard Six Cities Study and the American Cancer Society's Cancer Prevention Study II in setting the 1997 National Ambient Air Quality Standard for particulate matter. Industrial stakeholders argued that the data should be available for analysis by affected parties because of the sweeping consequences of the proposed standard. The impetus for data sharing that originated with the Shelby Amendment has been reinforced by the culture of rapid data sharing that came with genomic research.1 As a starting point for considering data sharing in epidemiology, the nature of the data to be shared needs specification. “Data” has been broadly defined as “a collection of items of information,”2 whereas Wikipedia gives the following description: “Data (singular: datum) are collected of natural phenomena descriptors including the results of experience, observation or experiment, or a set of premises. This may consist of numbers, words, or images, particularly as measurements or observations of a set of variables.”3 Should sharing then extend to all data elements that might be collected or generated during the course of an epidemiologic study? Should sharing stop at analytical data sets? Some difficult scenarios of requests can be readily offered: raw electrocardiogram data rather than coded results; dietary consumption data rather than nutrient indices; and raw microarray data before processing to generate analytic variables. Requests could potentially extend to generated variables and related code and perhaps to simulated data sets. This listing is not meant to cause apprehension but to anticipate the kinds of requests that might be made for study “data.” Surprisingly little has been written in the epidemiologic literature directly on data sharing. A 1991 commentary by Hogue,4 written on behalf of an ad hoc committee of the Society for Epidemiological Research, addressed ethical and other issues in data sharing. Read now, the commentary still speaks to currently active issues. It calls for data sharing but covers most of the same issues that are still perceived as barriers to doing so. The American College of Epidemiology published a policy statement on data sharing in 2002 (http://www.acepidemiology.org/policystmts/DataSharing.pdf). The statement covered the benefits and challenges of data sharing and offered principles that should underlie data sharing. The current views of academic epidemiologists have been widely influenced by the NIH, which, since 2003 has required a data-sharing plan for all grants with funding exceeding $500,000 in any year. Even so, we know little about how investigators have responded to this requirement and the consequences, both immediate and for the future of the new policy. More recently, for genome-wide association studies, the NIH is giving investigators 12 months of exclusivity before sharing data.5 Among researchers, there is now growing understanding of the implications of data sharing and of the potential effort involved in doing so. I have received requests for several decades for data sets that my colleagues and I had developed. In the past, requests came rarely and typically involved a letter, sometimes apologetic in tone for the request, and a follow-up phone call and even in-person meetings. The mechanisms for sharing data were primitive: generating a data set that might be sent via a tape to be read on a mainframe computer. Now, the requests are frequent and come via email; they arrive from all over the world and may be made by academic or nonacademic researchers, and frequ
Cited by 19 works. doi:10.1097/ede.0b013e3181930df3
Authors
References
- A Dictionary of Epidemiology
- The National Morbidity, Mortality, and Air Pollution Study. Part II: Morbidity and mortality from air pollution in the United States.
- Reproducible Epidemiologic Research
- Scholarship in the Digital Age
- An International Framework to Promote Access to Data
- Share and share alike: deciding how to distribute the scientific and social benefits of genomic data
- The Evolution of Epidemiologic Research
- Ethical issues in sharing epidemiologic data
- ???Big??? Science and the Little Guy
- How Big Is Big Enough for Epidemiology?