Moving Beyond the Hazard Ratio in Quantifying the Between-Group Difference in Survival Analysis
Hajime Uno, Brian Lee Claggett, Lü Tian et al. · Journal of Clinical Oncology · 2014
In a longitudinal clinical study to compare two groups, the primary end point is often the time to a specific event (eg, disease progression, death). The hazard ratio estimate is routinely used to empirically quantify the between-group difference under the assumption that the ratio of the two hazard functions is approximately constant over time. When this assumption is plausible, such a ratio estimate may capture the relative difference between two survival curves. However, the clinical meaning of such a ratio estimate is difficult, if not impossible, to interpret when the underlying proportional hazards assumption is violated (ie, the hazard ratio is not constant over time). Although this issue has been studied extensively and various alternatives to the hazard ratio estimator have been discussed in the statistical literature, such crucial information does not seem to have reached the broader community of health science researchers. In this article, we summarize several critical concerns regarding this conventional practice and discuss various well-known alternatives for quantifying the underlying differences between groups with respect to a time-to-event end point. The data from three recent cancer clinical trials, which reflect a variety of scenarios, are used throughout to illustrate our discussions. When there is not sufficient information about the profile of the between-group difference at the design stage of the study, we encourage practitioners to consider a prespecified, clinically meaningful, model-free measure for quantifying the difference and to use robust estimation procedures to draw primary inferences.
Cited by 810 works. doi:10.1200/jco.2014.55.2208
Authors
- Hajime Uno
- Brian Lee Claggett
- Lü Tian
- Eisuke Inoue
- Paul P. Gallo
- Toshio Miyata
- Deborah Schrag
- Masahiro Takeuchi
- Yoshiaki Uyama
- Lihui Zhao
- Hicham Skali
- Scott David Solomon
- Susanna Joan Jacobus
- Milton Packer
- L. J. Wei
References
- Regression Models and Life-Tables
- Regression Models and Life-Tables
- An Introduction to the Bootstrap
- The Statistical Analysis of Failure Time Data.
- An Introduction to the Bootstrap
- Analysis of Survival Data
- Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions
- Analysis of Survival Data.
- CONSORT 2010 Explanation and Elaboration: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials
- The Robust Inference for the Cox Proportional Hazards Model