Single Reading with Computer-Aided Detection for Screening Mammography
Fiona J. Gilbert, Susan Astley, Maureen Gc Gillan et al. · New England Journal of Medicine · 2008
BACKGROUND: The sensitivity of screening mammography for the detection of small breast cancers is higher when the mammogram is read by two readers rather than by a single reader. We conducted a trial to determine whether the performance of a single reader using a computer-aided detection system would match the performance achieved by two readers. METHODS: The trial was designed as an equivalence trial, with matched-pair comparisons between the cancer-detection rates achieved by single reading with computer-aided detection and those achieved by double reading. We randomly assigned 31,057 women undergoing routine screening by film mammography at three centers in England to double reading, single reading with computer-aided detection, or both double reading and single reading with computer-aided detection, at a ratio of 1:1:28. The primary outcome measures were the proportion of cancers detected according to regimen and the recall rates within the group receiving both reading regimens. RESULTS: The proportion of cancers detected was 199 of 227 (87.7%) for double reading and 198 of 227 (87.2%) for single reading with computer-aided detection (P=0.89). The overall recall rates were 3.4% for double reading and 3.9% for single reading with computer-aided detection; the difference between the rates was small but significant (P<0.001). The estimated sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value for single reading with computer-aided detection were 87.2%, 96.9%, and 18.0%, respectively. The corresponding values for double reading were 87.7%, 97.4%, and 21.1%. There were no significant differences between the pathological attributes of tumors detected by single reading with computer-aided detection alone and those of tumors detected by double reading alone. CONCLUSIONS: Single reading with computer-aided detection could be an alternative to double reading and could improve the rate of detection of cancer from screening mammograms read by a single reader. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00450359.)
Cited by 296 works. doi:10.1056/nejmoa0803545
Authors
- Fiona J. Gilbert
- Susan Astley
- Maureen Gc Gillan
- Olorunsola F. Agbaje
- Matthew Wallis
- Jonathan J. James
- Caroline R. M. Boggis
- S.W. Duffy
References
- Note on the Sampling Error of the Difference Between Correlated Proportions or Percentages
- Trials to assess equivalence: the importance of rigorous methods: Fig 1
- Efficacy and Safety of Tenofovir DF vs Stavudine in Combination Therapy in Antiretroviral-Naive Patients A 3-Year Randomized Trial
- Screening Mammography with Computer-aided Detection: Prospective Study of 12,860 Patients in a Community Breast Center
- Potential Contribution of Computer-aided Detection to the Sensitivity of Screening Mammography
- Influence of Computer-Aided Detection on Performance of Screening Mammography
- Statistical Issues in Drug Development
- Changes in Breast Cancer Detection and Mammography Recall Rates After the Introduction of a Computer-Aided Detection System
- Mammographic Characteristics of 115 Missed Cancers Later Detected with Screening Mammography and the Potential Utility of Computer-aided Detection
- Comparison of Screening Mammography in the United States and the United Kingdom