Introduction to a Collection of Physical Activity Questionnaires

Andrea M. Kriska, Carl J. Caspersen · Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise · 1997

Physical activity has emerged as an important risk factor for many chronic diseases, such as coronary heart disease and diabetes. As part of an effort to improve public health by increasing physical activity levels of the nation, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the American College of Sports Medicine (26), the U.S. Public Health Service (35), the National Institutes of Health(23), and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Service(34) have included activity recommendations. Recognition of the importance of physical activity to the nation's health has also influenced all public health research; most population studies that examine chronic diseases incorporate the assessment of physical activity into their study design. Physical activity was defined by Caspersen et al. (5) as “any bodily movement produced by skeletal muscles that results in energy expenditure.” Components of total energy expenditure include basal metabolic rate, which typically encompasses 50%-70% of total energy expended; the thermic effect of food, which accounts for another 7-10%; and physical activity (28,30). This last component, physical activity, is the most variable component and is comprised of activities of daily living (bathing, feeding, and grooming, for example), sports and leisure, and occupational activities. The share of total energy expenditure accounted for by physical activity is obviously greater for active individuals. Measurement of Physical Activity Valid and appropriate measurement of physical activity is a challenging task, because the relative contribution of each of these components can vary considerably both within and among individuals and populations. Measurement is further complicated because there are several health-related dimensions of physical activity, such as caloric expenditure, aerobic intensity, weight bearing, flexibility, and strength (4). Differences in these aspects of physical activity may have implications for the prevention of specific diseases. For example, 100 calories expended swimming may be particularly beneficial to cardiovascular health and the prevention of related diseases, whereas 100 calories expended weight training may have a more favorable effect on bone mass or osteoporosis risk. In examining the relationship between physical activity and a disease or condition, it is therefore important to focus on the dimension (or dimensions) of physical activity most likely to be associated with the specific outcome of interest. The quality of the measure of physical activity is another important concern. Poor quality measures can obscure important associations, as shown by a methodologic critique of coronary heart disease studies conducted prior to 1986. The critique found that 40% of the measures were“unsatisfactory,” 40% were “satisfactory,” and only 20% were “good” (4,27). As the quality of the physical activity measure increased from unsatisfactory to good, the proportion of studies revealing a statistically significant association increased from approximately 50% to 88% (4,27). The critique noted that the quality of the physical activity measures was poorer than that of the coronary heart disease measures(4,27). The difficulty of ensuring the quality and accuracy of measurements of various health-related dimensions of physical activity will also limit the ability to detect significant associations between physical activity and disease outcomes (17). The Survey Approach versus Other Assessment Tools Physical activity assessment tools have been used to measure various dimensions and attributes of physical activity. Most assessment tools used to measure physical activity have focused on the amount of energy expended(16). The advantages and disadvantages of these different approaches depend upon the population being studied and the research objectives. Epidemiologic studies have typically used subjective measures, such as the questionnaire, to assess physical activity in populations. Such studies then used objective measures to validate the subjective activity measures. Popular objective activity assessment tools include measures of total energy expenditure, such as the doubly labeled water technique and the respiratory chamber; movement counters, which initially measured frequency of movement and have progressively been modified to detect differences in speed and direction of movement; and measures that estimate physical fitness, such as heart rate monitoring and graded exercise testing. The physical activity questionnaire is typically chosen for population studies because it possesses the characteristics of non-reactiveness (it does not alter the behavior of the individual being surveyed), practicality (there are reasonable study cost and participant convenience), applicability (the instrument can be designed to suit the particular population in question), and accuracy (it is both reliable and valid) (17,20). By contrast, objective measurements of energy expenditure, some of which have the advantage of providing more precise estimates of energy expenditure (the respiratory chamber or the doubly labeled water technique) are not practical for most epidemiologic studies, but they have been used to validate the physical activity questionnaire (17,20,29). However, the estimates obtained by the activity questionnaire are valuable in relative terms and can be used to rank individuals or groups of subjects within a population from the least to the most active. The ranking can then be examined with respect to physiologic parameters and disease outcomes(13). Complexity of surveys. The survey approaches used to measure physical activity vary in their complexity, from self-administered, single-item questions to interviewer-administered surveys of lifetime physical activity. Single-item questionnaires may ask individuals whether the person surveyed is more active than others of their age and sex(22) or whether the person exercises long enough to break a sweat (39)

Cited by 446 works. doi:10.1097/00005768-199706001-00003

Authors

References