The Pugh Controlled Convergence method: model-based evaluation and implications for design theory
Daniel Frey, Paulien Herder, Ype C. Wijnia et al. · Research in Engineering Design · 2008
This paper evaluates the Pugh Controlled Convergence method and its relationship to recent developments in design theory. Computer executable models are proposed simulating a team of people involved in iterated cycles of evaluation, ideation, and investigation. The models suggest that: (1) convergence of the set of design concepts is facilitated by the selection of a strong datum concept; (2) iterated use of an evaluation matrix can facilitate convergence of expert opinion, especially if used to plan investigations conducted between matrix runs; and (3) ideation stimulated by the Pugh matrices can provide large benefits both by improving the set of alternatives and by facilitating convergence. As a basis of comparison, alternatives to Pugh’s methods were assessed such as using a single summary criterion or using a Borda count. These models suggest that Pugh’s method, under a substantial range of assumptions, results in better design outcomes than those from these alternative procedures.
Cited by 108 works. doi:10.1007/s00163-008-0056-z Open-access PDF
Authors
- Daniel Frey
- Paulien Herder
- Ype C. Wijnia
- Eswaran Subrahmanian
- Konstantinos V. Katsikopoulos
- Don P. Clausing
References
- Theory of games and economic behavior
- Social Choice and Individual Values.
- Technical Change and the Aggregate Production Function
- Theory of Games and Economic Behavior
- Empirical Model Building and Response Surfaces
- Social Choice and Individual Values
- Empirical Model-Building and Response Surfaces.
- Engineering Design: A Systematic Approach
- Simple Heuristics That Make Us Smart
- Emotion, Decision Making and the Orbitofrontal Cortex