《壇經》的作者與版本-印順與胡適及日本學者相關研究觀點之比較
邱敏捷 · 2007
The problems of the author and version of Altar Scriptures are the cruxes to the history of the Chinese Zen in the early days. Taking the ”Author and Version of Altar Scriptures-A Comparative Study of Related Research Viewpoints among Yin Shun, Hu Shih and Japanese Scholars” as the theme, this paper aims at studying and comparing the research results of Yin Shun and so on over these aspects. Hu Shih thinks that the author of Altar Scriptures should be Shen Huei and Dunhuang version is the most ancient version of Altar Scriptures. Suzuki Daisetsu argues that Altar Scriptures is a work passed on to the later generations from the Southern Master, and thus its version goes through changes along with time. Ui Hakuju indicates that Altar Scriptures may be gradually revised and enlarged, and has gone through at least two revisions. Employing a different path, Sekiguchi Mahiro refers to the suspected ideas of Huei Neng in Interpretation of Jin-gang Scriptures according to the legend, and believes that Altar Scriptures represents the thinking of Shen Huei. He gives evidence and reasons that Altar Scriptures cannot represent the ideas of Huei Neng. He mentions that the two volumes of Interpretation of Jin-gang Scriptures, or the suspected ideas of Huei Neng, are consistent with Pithy Formulas of Jin-gang Scriptures. He suggests that Jin-gang Ban-ruo-mi Scriptures is the blueprint of Huei Neng's thinking. However, Yanagida Seizan has a different point of view. He thinks that Altar Scriptures is a mixed product of Niu-tou Master and Southern Master, and that Lelin Fahai of Niu-tou Master is very probably the author of this book. Yin Shun thinks that the main body of Altar Scriptures is just ”Teaching of Da-fan Temple.” He trusts that the Dunhuang version of Altar Scriptures has gone through at least two revisions: one refers to the revision of Altar Scriptures as mentioned by Huei Jhong of Nanyang, and the so-called ”Southern Objectives,” and the other refers to the Altar Scriptures passed on by the disciples of Shen Huei. Above all, over the issues of the author and version of Altar Scriptures, Yin Shun, Hu Shih and each of those Japanese scholars have their own evidences and points of view.
Cited by 0 works. doi:10.7029/jhss.200710.0013