철학자들에 대한 알 가잘리의 비판과 그 정치적 배경

김정명 · 한국이슬람학회 논총 · 2003

Al-Ghaza ̄li(1058-1111), the great Ash`arite theologian, is well known as the author of Incoherence of philosophers(Taha ̄fut al-Fala ̄sifa). In this work, he discussed twenty questions of philosophical doctrine in which he regarded philosophers as mistaken and misguided. Especially three of them he denounced as more serious than the others and tantamount to infidelity. The three doctrines are: the eternality of the world, God`s ignorance of the particulars , and the denial of bodily resurrection. He has completed the work in 1095. After about 10 years, he wrote Difference between Islam and Zandagah(Faysal al-Tafriga Bayn al-Islam wa `1-Zandagah) to expound the legal ground upon which he condemned the philosophers to infidelity. Here we can say that al-Ghazali was very sincere and consistent in the rejection of philosophy throughout his lifetime. This paper aims to understand the reason why al-Ghaza ̄li attacked the philosophers. To do this job, al-Ghaza ̄li`s main works such as Incoherence of philosophers and Difference between Islam and Zandaqa will be analyzed in detail. This paper consists of 5 parts: 1. Introduction, 2. Whom does al-Ghaza ̄h exactly mean by the name `philosophers`?, 3. The pronouncement of infidelity and the three philosophical doctrines, 4. The pronouncement of infidelity and its political background. As conclusions, following points will be mentioned. First, In Incoherence of philosophers, al-Ghaza ̄li`s attack was mainly focused on Ibn Sina. All of the three philosophical doctrines, upon which he denounced the philosophers as infidels, are Ibn Sina`s opinions appearing in his main works. Second, al-Ghaza ̄li made attacks on Ibn Sina as a preparation to attack Isma ̄`ilites. The Isma ̄`ilites, as a main Shi`ite sect, disapproved the `Abbasid caliphs and maintained political rivalry with them between 10th-12th centuries. After they established the Fatimid dynasty in 969, they started to threaten the `Abbasid government ideologically and militantly. AI-Ghaza ̄l` refuted the Isma ̄`ilites and Ibn Sina at the same time, because both of them belonged to the same neo-platonist trend. Third, the Ash`a ̄rite school , to which al-Ghaza ̄li belonged, has been traditionally involved in defending the `Abbasid government from the Isma ̄`ilites. Al-Ghaza ̄lt`s attack on Ibn Sina was a part of his political attaks on the Isma ̄`ilites.

Cited by 0 works.

Authors