데리다의 해체론에 대한 신학적 접근 가능성에 관한 일고
박종균 · Korean Journal of Christian Studies · 2003
The method of deconstruction is connected with what Derrida calls the ‘metaphysics of presence’. It is Derrida’s contention that traditional metaphysical philosophers rely on the assumption of an immediately available area of certainty. The origin and foundation of most philosophers’ theories is presence. Derrida, however, denies the possibility of this presence and in so doing removes the ground from which philosophers have in general proceeded. By denying presence, Derrida is denying that there is a present in the sense of a single definable moment which is ‘now’. Speech has been regarded as prior because it is closer to the possibility of presence. It is closer because speech implies immediacy. In speech meaning is apparently immanent, above all when, using the inner voice of consciousness, we speak to ourselves. In the moment of speech we appear to grasp its meaning and are thereby able to capture presence, as if the meaning was decided once and for all. Thus, unlike writing, speech is linked to the apparent moment and place of presence and for this reason has had priority over writing. For Derrida, therefore, phonocentrism is one of the effect of presence. Derrida’ s attempt to deconstruct the opposition between speech and writing is linked to the uncovering of the metaphysics of presence as a whole. Western philosophy is also ‘logocentric’. Western philosophy is assumed that there is an essence, or truth which acts as the foundation of all our beliefs ; hence there seems to be a disposition, a longing, for a ‘transcendental signifier’ which would directly relate, correspond, to a secure stable ‘transcendental signified’(Idea, God, Matter, etc.). This paper argues for the problems on the theological appropriation of Derrida’ s deconstructive thought. Within the interpretative framework the question of God is predetermined to result in ontological denial. For the orthodox theologians, deconstruction incites the presumption of the theology of God’s death. Theology therefore considers deconstruction as a nihilism. John Milbank as a representative criticizes nihilistic elements in deconstruction and rejects deconstruction as a possible theological partner. But I hope to manifest that more minute reading of the deconstructive thought of Derrida must reappraise this nihilist misunderstanding. Derrida’ s interest in the limits of language is precisely a recognition of the ‘other’ that can never be thought. This approacher will illustrate how this impossible thought prevents deconstruction from maintaining the type of nihilism. In this process, some relationship between deconstruction and negative theology, between deconstruction and theological paradox is illustrated, and the relationships deepen an understanding of common interests in faith and liberating discourse. I come to a conclusion that Derrida can help theology to escape nihilism, and to maintain the question of God.
Cited by 0 works.