쇄골 골절의 치료 결과에 대한 평가

송경진, 황병연, 장기영 · 1995

There is still controversies in the treatment of clavicle fracture between conservative versus operative treatment. We reviewed one hundred thirth-six patients(141 cases) treated conservatively and operatively since February 1981 to September 1993 at Chonbuk National University Hospital. The mean follow-up was forth-six months ranging from six months to twelve years. Fifty cases treated swgically and ninty-one cases treated conservatively. In the surgical treatment group, mostly treated with intramedullsry nailling with K-wires or Steinmann pin and plating with screws, with or without bone graft. We tried to evaluate the result of treatment between these two treatment groups in the viewpoint of criteria of pain, deformity, limitation of motion, subjective symptoms and disturbancc of daily activities and also in the viewpoint of complicatians like nonunion, malunion, motion limitaion, infection and metal failures. The mast common complication of the conservative treatment was malunion and nonunion was the most common complication in the operative treatment. Satisfactory results obtained in 89% of operative treatment group in the functional group and 88% of operative treatment group in the functional evaluation scale. Each clavicle fracture should be treated according to their degree of comminution, site of fracture, neurovascular injury, associated injury and doctor's experience as which cases can promptly be treated either conservatively or operatively. But we would like insist of surgical treatment for the cases necessitating surgery for the prevention of nonunion, malunion and joint stifhess what are common complications in the conservative

Cited by 0 works.

Authors