Категория "правовая жизнь" в основных конструктивных моментах
Черных Евгений Николаевич · Вісник Маріупольського державного університету. Сер.: Право · 2013
The article deals with theoretical problems of the category of which in the last decade has received considerable support of the Russian and Ukrainian scientists. This category aims extremely comprehensive reflection of all manifestations of the existence of law as a specific form of social life. The peculiarity of such approach is that the category of legal includes not only positive, but also negative manifestations of a legal nature (illegal). The article demonstrates that very large ontological problem, consisting in an attempt to fit into a single concept, all that is connected with legal regulation, generates epistemological problems: a mix of different cognitive strategies and instruments; the discrepancy with the philosophical models of law; violation of rules of design for scientific categories, which is a result of underestimation of the axiological strategy. These results in a value inconsistent category, whose methodological centre of conflict is the element og illegal. The actual negative effects of the derived category are so formal, value-free, whithin the guiding methods becomes sociological concept rather than legal one. It is noted that due to the presence of negative effects in the structure of categories it has no criteria that can unite all its elements, which violates the principle of the structure of scientific concepts. However, the elimination of the element of illegal doesn’t sowe the category, since it deprives it of the general idea, a reflection of legal reality as the most social type of in all its fullness and contradictions. Attention is drown to the divergence of views regarding the characteristics of systematic category and legal life, and weakness of arguments about their advantages before other similar categories. According to the author, categories of legal provide us with an example that between law as a phenomenon of spiritual culture and the actual environment of its existence there is value inconsistency in the form of illegal, which does not allow to fully reconcile them in a single concept. The aim of the unification in the same legal category of the perfect sphere, of the legal prescriptions and imperfect world, which is converted by the law is attractive, but, in the author's opinion, is unlikely to be achieved. The findings of individual lauthors about significant heuristic potential categories of life against the background of methodological and constructive comments seem hasty.
Cited by 0 works.