Dummy Endogenous Variables in a Simultaneous Equation System

James J. Heckman · National Bureau of Economic Research · 1977

The models developed below rely critically on the notion that discrete endogenous variables are generated by continuous latent variables crossing thresholds.Such models have an honored place in the history of statistics and were first advanced by Pearson (1900).The theory of biserial and tetrathoric correlation is based on this idea.(See Kendall and Stuart, 1 Vol.II, 1967; Lord and Novick, cbs.16-20, 1967.)It is argued in this paper that this class of statistical models provides a natural framework for generating simultaneous equation models with both discrete and continuous random variables.In contrast, the framework of Goodman, while convenient for formulating descriptive models for discrete data, offers a much less natural apparatus for analyzing econometric structural equation models.This is so primarily because the simultaneous equation model is inherently an unconditional representation of behavioral equations while the model of Goodman is designed to facilitate the analysis of conditional representations, and does not lend itself to the unconditional formulations required in simultaneous equation theory.The structure of this paper is in four parts.in part one general models are discussed.Dummy endogenous variables are introduced in two distinct roles: (1) as proxies for unobserved latent variables and (2) as direct shifters of behavioral equations.Five models incorporating such dummy variables are discussed.Part two, also the longest section, presents a complete analysis of the most novel and most general of the five models presented in part one.This is a model with both continuous and discrete endogenous variables.The issues of identification and estimation are discussed together by proving the existence of consistent estimators.Maximum likelihood estimators and alternative estimators are discussed.In part three, a brief discussion of a multivariate probit model with structural shift is presented.Part four presents a comparison between the models developed in this paper and the models of Goodman and Nerlove and Press.

Cited by 1,837 works. doi:10.3386/w0177 Open-access PDF

Authors

References