선택발명인 거울상 이성질체 발명의 신규성 판단

정차호, 신혜은 · Seoul National University Open Repository (Seoul National University) · 2008

This paper suggests better jurisprudence on novelty determination of an enantiomer\n\ninvention, which is a type of selection invention. For the suggestion, it first crafts an\n\nupgraded definition of a selection invention and then analyzes standards of novelty\n\ndetermination of selection invention and enantiomer invention in the U.S.A, Europe,\n\nJapan and Korea. Based on such analysis, this paper proclaims new standards of\n\nnovelty determination of enantiomer invention as follows: (1) express disclosure\n\nrequirement must be case-by-case determined on whether resolution method from\n\nracemate to enantiomer at issue was specifically disclosed; (2) enabling requirement\n\nof prior art must be separately and additionally determined; (3) in determining\n\nexpress disclosure requirement, the concept of skilled person must not be applied and\n\nonly single prior must be compared; and (4) determination of enabling requirement\n\nmust be based on the skilled person's own knowledge. As a conclusion, this paper\n\nclaims that such law which fundamentally denies novelty of an enantiomer invention\n\nis not appropriate and that we should induce relevant research and development\n\nactivities by establishing a proper inventive step standard.

Cited by 0 works.

Authors