Collaborative benchmarking of functional-structural root architecture models: Quantitative comparison of simulated root water uptake
Andrea Schnepf, Christopher K. Black, Valentin Couvreur et al. · in silico Plants · 2023
Abstract Functional-structural root architecture models have evolved as tools for the design of improved agricultural management practices and for the selection of optimal root traits. In order to test their accuracy and reliability, we present the first benchmarking of root water uptake from soil using five well-established functional-structural root architecture models: DuMux, CPlantBox, R-SWMS, OpenSimRoot and SRI. The benchmark scenarios include basic tests for water flow in soil and roots as well as advanced tests for the coupled soil-root system. The reference solutions and the solutions of the different simulators are available through Jupyter Notebooks on a GitHub repository. All of the simulators were able to pass the basic tests and continued to perform well in the benchmarks for the coupled soil-plant system. For the advanced tests, we created an overview of the different ways of coupling the soil and the root domains as well as the different methods used to account for rhizosphere resistance to water flow. Although the methods used for coupling and modelling rhizosphere resistance were quite different, all simulators were in reasonably good agreement with the reference solution. During this benchmarking effort, individual simulators were able to learn about their strengths and challenges, while some were even able to improve their code. Some now include the benchmarks as standard tests within their codes. Additional model results may be added to the GitHub repository at any point in the future and will be automatically included in the comparison.
Cited by 18 works. doi:10.1093/insilicoplants/diad005 Open-access PDF
Authors
- Andrea Schnepf
- Christopher K. Black
- Valentin Couvreur
- Benjamin M. Delory
- Claude Doussan
- Adrien Heymans
- Mathieu Javaux
- Deepanshu Khare
- Axelle Koch
- Timo Koch
- Christian Kuppe
- Magdalena Landl
- Daniel Leitner
- Guillaume Lobet
- Félicien Meunier
- Johannes Auke Postma
- Ernst Schäfer
- Tobias Selzner
- Jan Vanderborght
- Harry Vereecken
References
- A general mass‐conservative numerical solution for the unsaturated flow equation
- Assessing agricultural risks of climate change in the 21st century in a global gridded crop model intercomparison
- Water Movement Through Plant Roots
- A generic grid interface for parallel and adaptive scientific computing. Part I: abstract framework
- DuMux: DUNE for multi-{phase,component,scale,physics,…} flow and transport in porous media
- Simultaneous modeling of transient three-dimensional root growth and soil water flow
- Use of a Three‐Dimensional Detailed Modeling Approach for Predicting Root Water Uptake
- A simulation model of the three-dimensional architecture of the maize root system
- Transient three-dimensional modeling of soil water and solute transport with simultaneous root growth, root water and nutrient uptake
- Water Uptake by Plant Roots: II – Modelling of Water Transfer in the Soil Root-system with Explicit Account of Flow within the Root System – Comparison with Experiments